IFRS Question 029: How to classify expenses in profit or loss statement under IFRS?

Dear Silvia, I am auditing a company who owns warehouses in several locations and rents the warehouses to other companies.

Last year, the company’s owners changed and as a result, there was a change in company’s operations.

Before, employees were assigned to the specific warehouse and worked in that warehouse only.

Now, employees rotate and can serve more warehouses over some time period.

On top of it, few administrative employees were fired and warehouse employees work on admin tasks, too.

So, we have a problem with classification of expenses.

Before, all salaries of warehouse employees were classified as cost of sales because they worked in warehouse.

Now, after the change, these salaries are classified simply as personnel expenses and as a result, cost of sales dramatically decreased.

How to solve this situation? Is this OK?
 

IFRS Answer 029

I like this question, because it deals with two issues:

  1. Classification of expenses in profit or loss, and
  2. Change in presentation of your profit or loss.

 

Classification of expenses in profit or loss

I often receive questions like:

  • How to present depreciation expenses?
  • How to present insurance of offices? And similar.

Let me say that you have a choice here.

The standard IAS 1 Presentation of financial statements does NOT prescribe how you should present your expenses.

In fact, there is NO mandatory format.

The reason is that every single entity is different in its activities and shows different profile of expenses necessary to achieve revenues.

Therefore, the standard requires the presentation of expenses in profit or loss in a way that provides more reliable and relevant information about your own activities.

Special For You! Have you already checked out the  IFRS Kit ? It’s a full IFRS learning package with more than 40 hours of private video tutorials, more than 140 IFRS case studies solved in Excel, more than 180 pages of handouts and many bonuses included. If you take action today and subscribe to the IFRS Kit, you’ll get it at discount! Click here to check it out!
 
It is true that the standard IAS 1 suggests 2 different formats:

  1. Expenses by nature and
  2. Expenses by function.

 

Expenses by nature

When you present by nature, then you simply group the expenses by their nature regardless the role that they play in your company.

You do NOT reallocate them among various functions in your company.

For example, the salary of warehouse employees and the salary of admin employees will be presented as personnel expenses.

Similarly, depreciation of warehouse and depreciation of admin building will be presented as depreciation expenses.

The big advantage of this method is that it is very simple because you don’t have to worry with allocations.
 

Expenses by function

Here, you group your expenses by the functions in your company.

For example, salary of warehouse employees and depreciation of warehouse are presented as cost of sales.

Salary of admin employees and depreciation of admin building are presented as administrative expenses.

This method is more demanding because it requires certain work and judgment when reallocating your expenses among various functions, but it is probably more relevant for some types of companies.
 

What classification to use?

And now, let me clarify that IAS 1 DOES NOT require analysis of expense by function or by nature on the face of profit or loss statement – it is a suggestion.

In fact, you are permitted to disclose the classification on the face of the profit or loss statement on some mixed basis.

For example, you present cost of sales as a function, then you present gross profit and then you present depreciation expenses – this is an element from by nature method. That’s the illustration of the mixed basis.
 

What about the change in presentation?

Let’s get back to the first part of today’s question:

It is OK to present salaries of employees as cost of sales to the extent they relate to their warehouse work.

And, it is also OK to present these salaries as personnel expenses, if this is more relevant for the company’s activities.

But here, the question contains one more element: change in presentation.

One year, the expenses were presented as cost of sales and another year, they were presented as personnel expenses.

Well, this is not permitted.

Instead, you should bear in mind another two requirements of IAS 1:

  1. Consistency of presentation.
    You need to retain the presentation and classification of items in the financial statements from one period to the next.

    You can change the presentation, but only when there is a change in entity’s operations and the new way of presenting would be more relevant.

    Or, when IFRS standards change.

  2. Comparative information

    If you make the change in presentation, you need to reclassify your comparative information, too.

    It means that if you presented salaries of warehouse employees as cost of sales in the previous period, and now you want to present them as personnel expenses – you can do it, but you need to reclassify these salaries in the previous reporting period to personnel expenses too in order to make previous and current numbers comparable.

    So, the company from today’s question needs to present the profit or loss from the previous period in a new format and thus the cost of sales won’t dramatically decrease and the two statements will be fully comparable.

Any comments or questions? Please let me know below – thank you!